Discuss this post

The Words We Use

Posted on February 4, 2009
by Anna Clark

America is fractured by a political divide. The media responds by pitting environmentalists and Christians against each other. Is it possible we are all fundamentally alike, only speaking different languages? We may never know unless more of us learn how to translate.

“Therefore, make it your habit to confess your sins to one another and to pray for one another, so that you may be healed. The prayer of a righteous person is powerful and effective.” James 5:16

Here’s my confession. Up until several years ago, I was a closet environmentalist at church and a closet Christian at work. When I entered the green scene five years ago, it was by way of a secular route: activism, and eventually, corporate sustainability. Talking about Jesus felt weird and out of place. So, I ended up becoming a walking jigsaw puzzle. All the pieces were in place and the picture looked great from far away, but a closer inspection revealed a lot of open seams. Although I was out of integrity with myself, it was the only way I knew how to operate.

Then one day, while doing research for a Sierra Club project, I attended an event to hear Dr. Matthew Sleeth speak about his book Serve God, Save the Planet. All of a sudden, it was like getting permission to mix my two passions together. In fact, it explained a lot that I hadn’t understood before. No wonder I had such enthusiasm for protecting the environment. All along what I was really trying to do was protect God’s creation! In working to heal the planet, I was also trying to heal my relationship with God.

Since that day, I’ve worked on bridging my faith with my work, which leads to some very interesting (for me), and sometimes awkward (for others), conversations. Among Christians, I can't help bringing up the environment, and among environmentalists, I find myself talking about God. These conversations have made me realize that, as Americans, it has been a long time since we really talked to each other and perhaps even longer since we really talked about Him (outside of church, that is).

Many of us have never read the Bible cover to cover. And yet, in today’s sound bite culture, you can find an enormous number of Christians who boil down the whole of humanity’s relationship with the natural world to a single word: Dominion.
On the flip side, we have the secular environmentalists. In the eyes of believers, these activists come off like walking billboards advertising an angry message. Finally, when everyone turns a deaf ear to each other, both sides end up preaching to the choir and we wonder why we don’t have more new converts.

This hit home the day I attended a business networking lunch. I exchanged cards with a woman named Sally, a speaker, a writer, and a Christian. It looked like we shared a lot in common. Wanting to get to know her better, I asked about her work. “I’m building my motivational speaking business, but my day job is in marketing with Chick Fil’A,“ she told me. “Oh, I hear that’s a great company,” I said. Curious, I asked, “Do you happen to know how your company ranks in terms of corporate social responsibility? How about animal rights? How do they treat their chickens?” She looked at me like I had grown horns. She gave a short guffaw and her tone cooled, “Um, let’s see. How do we treat our chickens? We kill them. Animals don’t have feelings or rights.”

Wham! I felt like I’d been slapped. “Oh, I didn’t mean to offend you,” I stammered. “I know where we humans rank on the food chain, but it doesn’t mean that we should treat animals inhumanely,” I explained. Somehow she managed to smooth my feathers (no pun intended) and we parted ways amicably. I have respect for her even though I can’t understand her lack of enthusiasm for my cause. I guess that’s an invitation to continue the conversation.

What came up for me from that exchange is that some disagreements simply come down to the words we use. Sally balked at “animal rights” but relaxed when I downshifted to “humane treatment.” Is it possible that we are all fundamentally alike, but just speaking different languages? We may never know unless more of us learn how to translate.

I’m excited about the path God has put me on. The reason I know it is His idea that I become this kind of “translator” is because it feels so darned uncomfortable. This wasn’t exactly what I signed up for when I got into sustainability. And yet, it’s thrilling to have found a way to serve Him and others. I prayed that I would find a way to make a difference, and now I’ve found it. Having awkward conversations isn’t always easy, but part of me loves to rock the boat, so it’s a natural fit. I am glad to get to share these conversations with other Creation Care enthusiasts so that you might find your own voice, too. Visit this column each week to help me keep the conversation going.

Anna Clark is president of EarthPeople, a Dallas-based sustainability consulting firm. She is an author, a motivational speaker, a columnist for Greenbiz.com, and a regular contributor to SustainLane. Anna lives in Dallas with her husband Michael, their toddlers Jordan and Ryan, and their pet Bullmastiff named Casper. Their home is the second LEED-certified Platinum residence in Dallas.

Comments

Tyson S.
2/6/2009 12:18 pm

Tyson S. says:

Thanks for writing this article, Anna. I can completely identify with you about the false dichotomy between environmentalism and Christianity, and agree that much of it may be because of the words we use.

Ben DeVries
11/16/2009 8:44 pm

Ben DeVries says:

This is yet another very meaningful reflection, Anna. I can sense the dilemma you're describing very acutely in the field of animal advocacy. Especially in conservative communities, Christian even more so, there is an almost immediate reference point of 'animal rights' and PETA's extremism, let alone the perception that the Bible doesn't address the issue, which can be very substantial if partially subconscious (as you mentioned in your post on conservatism) barriers to overcome. And yet, the main message I hope to communicate personally and via Not One Sparrow is ultimately a very simple, and faithful, one: that God created animals, that He continues to watch over them and care for their wellbeing, and that He cares very much how we steward them as His image-bearers. I try to reframe the issue as best I can. Matthew Scully did an excellent job of that in his book 'Dominion,' I thought. By the way, I also appreciate you shining some light on Chick Fil'A. They have very outspoken Christian leadership, which is great, and apparently a strong track record of caring for their employees, which is wonderful, but I've often wanted to see them challenged on their use of animals and no doubt the sources they get them from - Ben

post commentPost a comment:

Get Started

Write a Review Post to SustainLane Add Green Products & Businesses

Written by Anna Clark

Anna Clark

Anna M. Clark is the author of the book "Green, American Style." She is the president of EarthPeople and blogs on sustainability and leadership. She resides with her family in one of Dallas’ first residences to earn the Platinum LEED certification from the U.S. Green Building Council. More About Anna »

Advertisement

Share eco-tips, reviews, news,
how-tos, or just blog it.

Get Started