Related Pages: Eat & Drink, Food & Grocery,

Green Score:
 
 
32% (1 user vote) What's this?
 
Thumb Up
Good for Me
Good for me (0/1)
Good for community
Good for the community (0/1)
Good for planet
Good for the planet (0/1)
Thumb Down
Over-hyped
Over-hyped (1/1)
Too expensive
Too expensive (0/1)
Doesn't work
Doesn't work (1/1)

Reviews of Wal-Mart

Wal-Mart
1 star rating
Adam W.
May 12, 2008
Adam W. 134 reviews Send Message | Add to Friends

No Love

I can see why people want Wal-Mart to go green. I understand the arguments. i understand that it means more people having the opportunity to buy organic food than ever before. I understand that Wal-Mart selling CFL light bulbs will mean less carbon for all of us.I understand it means an opportunity to make the largest change in the shortest amount of time. I agree with all of this.

What I don't agree with is that these benefits outweigh the negatives. The negatives are many. One at the top of the list is that Wal-Mart is now using it's mega lobbying power to try and water down the meaning of the word organic. That is a move that benefits only Wal-Mart. Additionally, by expending into this new market, Wal-Mart is trying to get people to ignore all of it's other problems, like the fact that it underpays workers and drives local businesses out of business. Plus, Wal-Mart by nature encourages mass consumption. That is exactly what we need to move away from in a more eco-friendly world. In my opinion, the very essence of what Wal-Mart is is not green, so no matter how many green initiatives it moves forward, we would be better of if it didn't exist at all.

Was this review helpful to you? Yes No

User Comments:

James E. says:
Hey Adam, I can appreciate your frustration. But consider this, EVERY MONTH 100 million shoppers go into Wal*Mart stores...a third of the population. The place isn't going away anytime soon. For better or worse, they are... more »

Ed G. says:
This is a case that calls for a review of the term "green". Adam's points are all completely valid, but "green" is not a religion, where you either buy into the entire program or you're tossed. It would be beyond... more »

SustainLane Newsletter Sign-up