Related Pages: Eat & Drink, Food & Grocery, walmart
www.nytimes.com/2006/05/14/o...
Description: Mega-Store
Category:
Eat & Drink, Food & Grocery
Keywords:
walmart
I can see why people want Wal-Mart to go green. I understand the arguments. i understand that it means more people having the opportunity to buy organic food than ever before. I understand that Wal-Mart selling CFL light bulbs will mean less carbon for all of us.I understand it means an opportunity to make the largest change in the shortest amount of time. I agree with all of this.
What I don't agree with is that these benefits outweigh the negatives. The negatives are many. One at the top of the list is that Wal-Mart is now using it's mega lobbying power to try and water down the meaning of the word organic. That is a move that benefits only Wal-Mart. Additionally, by expending into this new market, Wal-Mart is trying to get people to ignore all of it's other problems, like the fact that it underpays workers and drives local businesses out of business. Plus, Wal-Mart by nature encourages mass consumption. That is exactly what we need to move away from in a more eco-friendly world. In my opinion, the very essence of what Wal-Mart is is not green, so no matter how many green initiatives it moves forward, we would be better of if it didn't exist at all.
User Comments:
James E. says:
Hey Adam, I can appreciate your frustration. But consider this, EVERY MONTH 100 million shoppers go into Wal*Mart stores...a third of the population. The place isn't going away anytime soon. For better or worse, they are... more »
Ed G. says:
This is a case that calls for a review of the term "green". Adam's points are all completely valid, but "green" is not a religion, where you either buy into the entire program or you're tossed. It would be beyond... more »