<< Air Quality | City Innovation >>
How We Rated Cities
Data was collected from the US Bureau of the Census/American Fact Finder.
Washington, D.C. continues to lead the nation in this category, with the second-highest use of public transit at more than 37 percent. It also boasts the second highest walk-to-work rating (more than nine percent), and above-average bike-to-work ratings. More than seven percent of Washingtonians also carpool.
Following close behind are number two-- New York City--leading the nation in public transit use with more than half of city residents commuting on it, and number three-ranked Boston, which has good all-around commute rates in public transit and the nation's highest walk-to-work rate: 12.55 percent. San Francisco and Philadelphia are numbers four and five respectively -- both have excellent or good public transit ridership rates.
At the bottom end of the spectrum are cities with less than two percent of residents commuting on public transit, and less than a single percent walking to work.
Denver, with a five percent commute-to-work rate on public transit, has plans to increase that figure four or fivefold over the next decades through ambitious transit-oriented development.
The advantages of car-free commuting are clear: less gasoline use per resident, safer streets, more vivid and bustling downtowns, and….deep breath… cleaner air.
Bicycle and train culture are set to become a back-to-the-future American "Mega-Trend" in 2009 and beyond. Our data shows that between 2004 and 2005 (the latest Census data available), bicycling across the 50 largest cities increased by 12.3 percent. Given what we've seen on the street around the country, and keeping tabs on gas prices using GasBuddy.com, we remain virtually certain that bicycling will become an increasingly common -- and socially accepted -- way to get around. Not to mention, it will help our country's overall physical fitness: no more driving to the gym! Finally, we'll realize reduced global warming-inducing CO2 emissions.
Taking public transit (trains, buses, ferries) to work increased by a meager yet respectable 1.59 percent. We chalk up this difference versus other modes to the ease of switching from solo car commuting to cycling or carpooling. Bicycles are cheap and cars are already there. You can't go out to WalMart and buy a commuter train yet -- at least not on your own. Plus, trains no longer exist in many major American cities and it’s no easy feat to get a train system up and running, even after it’s been approved. (Think land purchase, laying down tracks, purchasing trains….you get the idea). Lucky residents in Phoenix will be able to catch a ride on their city's new light rail by Christmas 2008. Thank you Santa!
Moving along: Walking to work increased countrywide in 2008 by 7.08 percent. And carpooling to work increased by 6.35 percent.
Although higher energy prices surely play the largest role in all these upswings, changing demographics (more elders, singles, and falling wages) are not bit characters to the mobility scene.
Movers and Shakers
Most Improved: Albuquerque (+17), Columbus (+12), San Diego (+11), Sacramento (+10), Mesa , (+9)
Least Improved: Houston (-8), Louisville (-8), Jacksonville (-8), Tulsa (-9), Arlington , TX (-11)
RAW DATA: BICYCLING TO WORK
Top 5 Cities for Bicycling
Whatever you thought about bicycling as a kid, it's back into vogue in the States. Although not nearly as popular as during the "Gay Nineties", pedaling around for everyday reasons has been common in these mostly League of American Bicyclist-recognized(*) cities for some time now.
Bottom 5 Cities for Bicycling
Just because these cities are lagging doesn't mean they can't improve. Any city can give bicyclist access a serious look, develop a plan, and create a more cycle-friendly environment.
RAW DATA: WALKING TO WORK
Top 5 Cities for Walking
Also as seen on WalkScore! These cities have graceful public spaces, short blocks, connected neighborhoods, and dense, mixed use zoned districts.
Bottom 5 Cities for Walking
We surmise that the 5 laggards here need more sidewalks, interesting trails which lead to popular destinations, and less sprawled development, at least in their respective ostensibly downtown areas. To be fair, these sunbelt cities were developed during the post-World War II era of suburbanization of cheap gasoline and electricity. What will they do next?
RAW DATA: CARPOOLING
Top 5 Cities for Carpooling
This amount of carpooling indicates cities ripe for installation of light rail rapid commuter systems, or in the case of Fresno , a significant migrant agricultural workforce.
Bottom 5 Cities for Carpooling
In dense, walkable cities with world-class rapid transit, it makes little sense to circle downtown blocks looking for expensive and rare parking spaces, dodging pedestrians. Kansas City is currently the exception to the rule.
RAW DATA: PUBLIC TRANSIT USE
Top 5 Cities for Public Transit Use
With the exception of Washington , D.C. , every city here grew up in the horse and buggy days, with streetcar rail systems. The District of Columbia is part of the 1960-70s "graduating class" of newly subway-enabled cities, along with Atlanta (MARTA) and San Francisco Bay Area cities San Francisco and Oakland (BART). BART reaches regional airports, commuter rail systems CalTrain, ACE and Amtrak, and someday it may even roll down to suburban San Jose . Atlanta is planning to extend MARTA with its back-to-the-future PeachTree Street Trolley and improved bus service.
Bottom 5 Cities for Public Transit Use
Surprise! These southern cities would benefit from re-installing light rail systems. Adding rail would provide residents relief from high gas prices -- and improve these cities' economic competitiveness. With air-conditioning thrown in, light rail would also provide relief from summer humidity.
| Write a Review | Tell Us How You Did It | Add Green Products & Businesses |
What are your thoughts on City Commuting? See what others are saying, or add your own comments.
Click here to comment!Seattle is at the forefront of all things Green. Our city has worked very hard to be #1 in Energy and Climate Change Policy and Innovation, and we're proud to be among the leaders in LEED Certified Buildings and the development of a Green Economy. These rankings provide the platform for friendly competition and a baseline for success. However, for us to be successful in the fight against Global Climate Change, every city has to embrace sustainable ideas such as smart growth, innovation, and progressive policy. Seattle is committed to do its part. —Mayor Greg Nickels, Seattle
US City Rankings, next edition!